Drink-related antisocial behaviour: Drunk Tanks, Minimum Pricing or new Laws won’t make any meaningful difference on their own and Government must accept that everyone involved has to play their part in tackling the fallout from this form of drug abuse…
Since I was first elected to the Chair of Tewkesbury Borough Council’s Licensing Committee, I have been grateful not only for my experience as someone who appreciates the concept of the Great British Pub, but also from that as a former CAMRA member and as a Personal License Holder in the work that has followed. It certainly helped in formulating a broad understanding of the current Licensing Laws and how they work in everyday practical terms.
Alcohol abuse and its knock on effects are and will continue to be a point of contention for anyone dealing with Licensing Law for so long as alcohol exists. The fact remains that were it to be discovered today, Alcohol in drink form would in all likelihood be classified as a Class A drug and under this guise would perhaps make many more people think differently towards its use than they currently do.
The reality is however that Alcohol hasn’t just been invented and with the genie having been well and truly out of the bottle for a considerable period of time, good regulation and management are the only effective ways that you will deal with this ‘legal high’ in a meaningful and long lasting way.
With this in mind, it is concerning to read that in response to the current discussion over privately-run ‘drunk tanks’, a Police Chief Constable has gone on the record to rubbish the 2003 Licensing Act and call for it to be scrapped when many of the principles within it do encourage a much improved level of professionalism and accountability within the Licensed Trade. The Law itself arguably only falls down because of the half hearted and ill-considered way that it has been rolled out.
To say that the issues surrounding Licensing are complex would be an understatement. The tail-end reforms of the 2003 Act within the Coalition’s Police Reform and Social Responsibility Act 2011 have ironed out a few of the rough edges left by the changes made to Licensing Law by the Blair Government. But it is still the overwhelming desire of Westminster Politicians to keep control of what those in Local Government do which creates the most harm when dealing with its application; all when the public are repetitively told that ‘Localism’ is supposed to be what the Coalition Government is all about.
One of those changes from 2011 which does give a small opportunity of genuine discretion to Licensing Authorities in what they do has been criticised by the Police because of its apparently slow roll out.
The ‘Late Night Levy’ or what is in practice a late hours surcharge for Licensed Premises opening into the early hours has in effect been left at the discretion of the Authorities themselves. Here we finally have an area of Local Government policy-making which might genuinely reflect the views of locally-elected Members and allow for consideration of the true impact that ballooning Regulatory Charges will have on existing pub businesses which in many cases simply couldn’t afford or justify them.
Understandably, this doesn’t sit well with Police Forces who not unlike just about every other public service throughout the Country are all looking for ways to increase income at a time when budgets are being repetitively slashed by Central Government.
This however isn’t good enough reason to rubbish the Licensing Laws as they stand, just as the problems with binge drinking and late night drink-related anti social behaviour should not be directly attributed to the Law itself.
It is the case that the problems should be attributed to the way the Policy has been applied and the failure of both this and the last Government to tie up the loose ends and then to proactively support the system that they have put in place between them.
Ironically, the 2003 Act provided Licensees – or Premises License Holders, with far more autonomy and responsibility for Licensed activities than they ever had before. Through the requirement of training and Licensing of Designated Premises Supervisors and the broad emphasis on promoting and embracing a culture of good practice, Licensed Premises should at least in theory be the safest places for Alcohol to be consumed and therefore the environment that Government really should be supporting.
The reality is however that the unhindered ease with which Retailers can obtain a Premises License both for ‘on’ or ‘off’ the premises consumption has made it horrifyingly simple for supermarkets to stack ‘em high and keep ‘em cheap when it comes to drink, without any real responsibility for what happens when the drink they have sold is consumed thereafter.
Local Licensing Authorities simply have no definitive power to dictate terms of Licenses which would reflect the true needs and requirements of any particular locality.
The one-size-fits-all approach of centrally-derived Licensing Regulation leaves Licensing Authorities being little more than administrators, unable to make truly ‘locality’ based decisions.
When they attempt to do so, applicants can simply appeal to the local Magistrates Court and will usually have little trouble getting anything overturned if their application technically meets Government guidelines – whatever the local issues and impact might actually be. I can clearly state that when the best that the Law allows a Licensing Committee to do is have their ‘concerns’ documented in the minutes of a hearing, you know that something simply isn’t working right.
Put a little more in context. ‘unregulated’, ‘unsupervised’ or drinking outside of a Licensed premises is a direct consequence of what some would consider to be a Licensing free-for-all and the frighteningly low prices at the tills that have made binge drinking as much – if not more of an issue than the ages old problem of alcoholism which itself is much more likely to be monitored and flagged with the watchful eyes of good publicans than it will do when simply kept behind closed doors.
Rather than support the resource and sometimes centralised social points for communities that pubs actually can be, successive Governments continue to oversee their demise and certainly fail to back up the application of their own Policies by stabilising and supporting these important hubs which could do so much more to assist in tackling what are very serious social issues if they were simply encouraged and aided to do so.
However, as things stand some 12 pubs close each and every week. In the majority of cases, these and their potential benefit will be lost to the communities around them forever.
Some will happily argue that pubs no longer have the appeal that they once did and this is why they are closing. There is some truth in this statement and not many can deny that the criminalisation of drink driving had a far reaching if unspoken affect on some venues as many people realised that the risks of having ‘a few’ were simply too high. Subsequently, social drinking for many lost the regularity that it may formally have had.
The Industry changed, especially so in isolated or rural locations where decision makers soon realised that pubs now had to have wider appeal and become a ‘destination’ – a route that for many has been found through serving food and the rise of the gastropub, where people now travel to eat, with drinking just being a consequence.
The ‘boozer’ as it was has since mutated to become what many now know as the ‘sports bar’ and it is perhaps these types of establishments which just revolve around drinking that are actually needed most of all but are more vulnerable to closure because taxation and the onset of the PubCo – the property portfolio owning organisations that charge ridiculous levels of rent for the pubs they own and then seek to take unrealistic margins off just about everything a pub sells via a ‘must buy through us’ caveat or ‘tie’ that makes many already struggling pubs simply impossible to run profitably.
Because of such ‘ties’, rented or leased pubs are left selling overpriced alcohol to customers who in today’s climate are driven greatly by price and rarely by the venue itself when alcohol consumption is the primary reason for going out.
Young people do much of their drinking before they even get to late night venues consuming cheap supermarket drink and yet there seems to be a view that it is these late night premises-based businesses that should pick up the tab, simply because they were the last place that the antisocial drunks had visited.
Few of us appreciate or actually condone antisocial behaviour, but the issues that lead people to behave in the way that they clearly do are reflective of a plethora of social issues which go way beyond the sale of Alcohol itself. As drug taking and drinking is considered by many to be an act of escapism for people who are unhappy at a deeper level, a good place for those in power to start this journey might very well be to ask the simple question ‘why’?
As a Licensing Chair, I do not believe the Government has anywhere near the full measure of the situation beyond that which it sees on paper. It is only through a process of change and of considering the full impact of all elements which are at play within the UK drinks industry and then by making policy changes which are real-solutions driven and take into account the role that all will play, that we will then have Laws in place that really will serve drinks producers, retailers, drinkers and the general public as best they can.
Without taking a comprehensive or ‘holistic’ approach like this, problems will continue and may well reach a point where options available right now, simply don’t exist even in the near future because the resources no longer exist to support them. My starting suggestions would be:
Level the playing field:
- Stop what is in effect pub ‘franchising’ and prevent price escalation through profiteering by PubCo’s. A simple way to do this would be to make it illegal for the owner or premises leaseholder of pubs to let or sub-let a pub to a third party within a contract that also places an obligation upon that tenant to buy any product from their landlord, their landlords agents or any company nominated by them.
- Forget minimum prices across the board, but stop off licenses and supermarkets from selling at or below the equivalent price of pubs in their Licensing Area. Making it illegal for retailers to undercut pubs would almost certainly make pubs more attractive for drinkers than they have been and take a lot of drinking off the streets. Retailers could be required to pay the additional margin or an appropriate tax into a scheme which could support local Policing and facilities such as drunk tanks, which with public services continuing to shrink, could still very much have a place.
Incentivise pub use:
- Lower duty on barrel and bulk supplied alcohol. This would potentially make pub alcohol cheaper still and would have the added environmentally friendly bonus of removing the need for all that packaging with pub glasses being reusable!
- Replace Business Rates on Pubs with a turnover related fee or supplementary tax. This would help new and struggling businesses to keep contributions relative to what they are earning and would have the benefit to the Local Authority of potentially contributing more when pubs are or have become more successful.
Give Licensing Authorities more scope:
- Let Licenses be set locally and limit the right of appeal. The Government should simply set Licensing principles and give the autonomy back to Councils to decide upon what terms Licenses should be granted against these with the balance of power in their interpretation placed back with the Authorities themselves and not ultimately with Magistrates who will arguably see Licensing Appeals as an unnecessary drain on their time. Local representatives are best placed to deal with local issues and no business should be able to just do what they want simply because they have the money available to exhaust the process to a level where those deciding are too far away from the issues placed within their care.
Tighten the existing Regulations:
- Make it a requirement that there is always a Personal License Holder either serving or within supervisory reach when a pub is serving. This would ensure that someone properly qualified and aware of the requirements of Licensing Legislation – but more importantly that the focus on responsible drinking are always maintained is on site and available to make decisions at all times.
There are likely to be many other tried, tested and also innovative ways that problems like drink related antisocial behaviour can be addressed, but this whole issue is a classic iceberg metaphor and very few of those with influence are looking very hard at what lies beneath the surface.
The wrong voices have too much power when it comes to Licensing related issues and more notice must be taken of UK wide interest groups like CAMRA and more localised community organisations, who have a definable cause promoting the interests of end users or the people who are actually affected at street-by-street level, rather than simple referral to the default-setting or usual suspect reference points such as Brewers, PubCo’s, Supermarkets and yes, the Police – all of whom do have particular and usually very specific motivations for pursuing a particular approach.
As with many areas of life where the Government is responsible for some form of legislation or service provision, the issues and key elements of the situation are often much more widespread than many realise.
The point here is that the general public simply will not experience genuine and long-term improvement until those in power actually consider all these factors and then delivers solutions which really are in the best interests of all the stakeholders involved, but primarily the people who put them there first.
Like Planning, Licensing must be put back in to local hands where an appropriate and real-life form of discretion can be applied to its use.
Rather than just tell us that they are all about Localism, the Government should actually be all about Localism and tackling the real-world realities of drink abuse, the behaviour of the industries behind it and the Licensing related issues which affect it would be one on a very long list of good places to start.
Share this:
Follow me on Twitter
My TweetsRecent Posts
- The Free School Meals and Child Food Poverty fiasco: Too much is being taken from too many – not because it’s right – but because those profiteering from misery are allowed by our Politicians to do so
- Cleeve.Cloud – Update
- War would have been less damaging to our Country than the Government’s response to Coronavirus because people would at least still want to live
- A 10-point plan to begin SAVING CLEEVE HILL GOLF COURSE
- The community can SAVE CLEEVE HILL GOLF COURSE. But don’t expect Tewkesbury Borough Council or any local politicians to do it on their own
- Embrace the Reset. Own the Reset. Make the Reset work for real people just like you. Don’t let the Reset be stolen and used against us all by the few
- There. Is. NO. CONSPIRACY. (Don’t get high on David Icke’s supply…)
- Show people a genuine alternative to this Government and System. Then they will join a movement for change
- The Chinese Government’s ruthlessness is a strategic risk empowered by the cultural fear Johnson & Co created to help their own plans for control
- A Gloucester shopkeeper has banned ALL customers not wearing a mask, insisting he is right to do so: This is what the Johnson Government has achieved by using fear to legitimise bullshit and lies
- Power and decision making should be as local to people as possible. It’s because it isn’t that so much with Public Policy is wrong
- Yes, Farage, Dolan and many other ‘names’ could play a part in what comes next. But their ideas, their passion and their anger only cover parts of what the comprehensive change we need is all about
- The real game in town is replacing this Government with the right people, not challenging everything they are getting wrong
- There’s nothing humane about algorithms being used to make life judgements and the A’ Level grade fiasco should be a lesson to us all
- Johnsons ‘Conservatives’ can use Thatcher memes as much as they like. There is a BIG difference between doing what is right for us all and doing what is right just for them
- These politicians wanted the job, the titles, the benefits and the glory that goes with it. But they never wanted or expected the responsibility and it has become plain for all of us to see
- Don’t fall into the trap of thinking the only issue with this Government is the Lockdown and what it has done since
- Forget planning a way out of the Government’s Coronavirus mess. Decisions have to be made in the moment and on the basis of doing what’s right
- Boris & Co. tout a V-shaped recovery whilst ONS GDP figures show a recession with everything going pear-shaped for the UK at best. Do we really want the idiots who created this mess left in charge of getting us out?
- This Government tyranny will be made worse by localising Test & Trace
- This unintentional tyranny is the worst kind of all
- #KBF & Simon Dolan RIGHTLY get the Lockdown case Appealed. But what difference would a win in Court really make?
- Extending the Furlough Scheme will not save jobs that have already gone. Improving it might at least save some of the small businesses that otherwise won’t survive
- The Government is set to legitimise planning madness for no good reason other than their own
- The majority won’t challenge the establishment until they themselves get burned
- When the Johnson Government falls, we don’t want a rehash of the old. We want something very special and very new
- Conspiracy theories will help the Government, not the anti-lockdown cause
- New Lords and the over 50s have something in common. They are the people most likely to cause Boris a problem as the wheels fall off
- The Banks will soon be begging for a bailout again. This time the Government MUST say NO
- It’s not the British People who are unable to use common sense, Boris
- Coronavirus is not a Government conspiracy: We just have politicians making stupid decisions
- We must change the way we see politics today so we can experience better politicians tomorrow
- If you want a change in Government approach and policy, you will have to change the Government and the politicians we elect first
- The SNPs progress on Scottish Independence is the EUs only UK success story. It was just a bit too late to seal a whole Nation’s fate:
- Process is the only thing holding government and the public sector together
- No Rishi, Money WILL NOT solve the problems that you and Boris created
- Chancellor to burn more Public Money subsidising Big Business whilst SMEs go to the wall
- If Coronavirus has only killed 1,366 people, WHY did we have the Lockdown and WHY does the massive injustice of Social Distancing continue?
- Boris condemned business with the lockdown, now he’s going to crucify them with a clawback too
- There’s nothing new about Boris’ New Deal
- Fire-hosing Cash into a Broken Economy won’t turn it around
- Corruption in Planning isn’t just about financial gain
- Only a new political movement will make sense of the mess that the UK is now in
- The false floor economy: when will it fall through?
- The genuine need for Free Meals is something this Government will never understand
- Boris’ Commission on systemic racism is a diversion that will not help or change anything
- Welcome to the deadly age of Groupthink where groups and ‘leaders’ aren’t thinking at all
- What Makes Anyone Racist?
- Our leaders aren’t leading. So who’s really in charge?
- Do businesses make staff redundant now or delay using furlough money until October?
- Sturgeon: Any path to Scottish Independence will do
- Solidarity is not reprisal.
- What will the true cost of the Lockdown be for our kids?
- China: The war we must win without ever fighting
- The NHS Test & Trace Service: The only certainty is the loss of freedom
- The War on Social Media: Is Trump the biggest Social Justice Warrior of them all?
- Cummings Statement: The elephants in the room and missed questions about the validity of the Lockdown
- No single cause deserves a bespoke package of help. We are in this together and ALL need the right support from Government to survive – just the same
- Social Distancing and the ‘requirement’ for PPE will finish off many businesses that the Lockdown didn’t
- Don’t make Cummings your sinner. We are all playing a part in keeping this ridiculous fear-based farce on track
- Don’t waste money challenging the Lockdown in Court. Fund a people’s movement for change instead
- Please stop the warnings. You are abusing your position and just making things worse
- We need a good dictator
- PLEASE! EVERYONE! Go back to work before there is no work to go back to!
- Don’t blame your Advisors – YOU were the ones appointed to lead and all of this was YOUR CHOICE
- Pay rises ARE NOT a lasting solution for Key Workers and the low-paid who ALL deserve more
- Whatever happens next Boris, please treat us like the adults we are and not the idiots you consider us to be
- The Social Distancing experience: Being herded like animals, treated as suspects and valued less than human
- COVID-19 has made No Deal a necessity for the UK as the EU clings on to the wreckage of its past
- For the love of God Boris, end the Lockdown now and sort out the mess you have created
- Teachers are not teaching our children during the Lockdown as they could and they should
- Keir Starmer will not be the man for all seasons that we now so desperately need.
- Unions must be stopped from using fear to make this crisis even worse. The problem is they are capitalising on what the Government did first
- Support local shops, farmers and suppliers today so they are there for you when other options no longer exist
- The only thing to fear about Coronavirus is the fear the Government created itself
- The PM and this Government are out of their depth and are relying on gimmicks and maintaining a false narrative to try and look credible
- Boris, it’s time to learn about making the right decisions for ‘everyone’ rather the right ones for ‘you’
- Desperate times ahead: Boris used clever slogans to scare us to death so we would stay at home. Now he has no easy way out
- Trains will run 90% empty after the Lockdown. Yes – this Government understands real life for sure…
- Both of my Grandfathers fought for the 75 years of Freedom we had that Boris Johnson ended on a whim in one day
- The Government has Bankrupted Britain whilst jumping into a trap that it will not climb out of if it continues to behave the same way
- We don’t want your App. We don’t want your Lockdown. We don’t want your manipulation or control. We want you to do your job or step aside so others can
- When our Government can’t make decisions on Coronavirus in the best interests of our own Country, it wont help to outsource them to Countries on the other side of the World
- If decision makers don’t understand their own lives how can they possibly make decisions for ours?
- The rise of the bookcase stasi shows us just how insular people populating the public sphere have become
- BUYER BEWARE! The voices speaking up against the Lockdown that appeared only 6 weeks in to it are riding the wave of public feeling like Boris once did
- BANKRUPT BRITAIN: No jobs, No small business, Debt, Hunger, Poverty, Homelessness & Suicides hanging from every tree. BUT IT WAS WORTH IT – Because Boris saved at least 3 people from COVID-19!
- There is a reset coming. It will be the opportunity to redress the balance of life in this country and make things fairer for all
- We need unknown voices to lead against the false populism of this Government, not the usual suspects who will repeat the same mistakes by choice
- The Lockdown is making less sense to more people everyday
- Suing the Government over the Lockdown won’t solve the problems and end the crisis they have created for us all
- Be the Herd.
- The only bounce coming for business will be from the explosion of the economy that Boris’ Lockdown bomb has created
- Is this the zombie apocalypse in reverse?
- COVID-19 has exposed just how sick the NHS and ALL public services were BEFORE this emergency began. Their future is YOURS to decide
- The Johnson Government will not be forgiven for harm it has caused us that it had the option to avoid
- We don’t live to work Chancellor. We want our lives back, not some halfway house and police state where only some of us can work and nothing else
- Using contact tracing with smartphones as the green light to end the Lockdown is dystopian measure and would consolidate the police state we are already in
- “Look everyone, we are testing a Vaccine” = Shut up and accept everything we tell you like the ignorant children you are
- Money is no longer god. Oil is just the start.
- We need the government to change its approach or for there to be a change in government NOW
- There’s only one way to exit the Lockdown: End it NOW – and stop trying to please everyone
- Politicians are using the Lockdown to play with our lives like it’s all a game. We need leadership at the top instead of privilege, and that change needs to happen before the UK as we know it is completely wrecked
- Don’t assume the Lockdown and 5G are part of a Conspiracy when Government stupidity can be blamed. It would be better to ask why normal people are already thinking this way
- The Nightingale ‘Field Hospitals’ look more like a cynical publicity stunt by the day. No Government should treat the public like this at any time and certainly not during a time of National Crisis
- Extending the Lockdown indefinitely until there is a vaccine is complete madness. This is not a war and the Government has choices that any Minister should be big enough to take
- Chancellor Rishi Sunak says the Government is being honest with people as he now tells us that he wont be able to protect every business. Neither statement is true
- The Johnson Government is high on its own supply of Lockdown and Coronavirus propaganda and completely out of touch with what people beyond the media-baited false populism think
- The NHS MUST be reformed after COVID-19 so that front line and clinical staff are valued as they should be whilst universal health provision for all remains something our Country can afford
- Some workers want this amount of money whilst others want more. But our needs are the same and government support is favoring some over others when we should all be getting exactly the same – not just in money but also support
- Media ‘celebrities’ are obsessed with being the news rather than conveying it. They hold a big part of the responsibility for the mess this Country is about to be in and its time for opinion dressed as news to stop.
- PETITION: END THE COVID-19 LOCKDOWN NOW
- Medical Experts should not be leading the response to a National Crisis. They clearly believe that tackling the medical part of the crisis is all our National response should be about
- Why it’s time to end the Lockdown & how to let life resume and face whatever happens next
- ‘Immunity Certificates’ will divide the Country socially and destroy it economically – if there is anything left to destroy
- 100,000 Coronavirus Tests per day by the end of April sounds great. But that’s still 600 days or the best part of 2 years before each person in the UK has been tested just ONCE
- The Government & Media has already set all of us on a downward spiral. The complete shutdown must be lifted now if we are to find a minimum-pain way out
- If you want to dob somebody in to the Police for doing the things you want to yourself – please don’t. Have a silent party in your head and celebrate that you have enough self control instead
- The World cannot stay stopped until a vaccine is found. Difficult choices need to be made
- Nobody else will ever compensate the loss of a good or viable business in circumstances out of the owner’s control. A Government that champions itself as the party of business should know better
- Yes, there are positives that are likely to come from this Crisis. The most significant will be a new ‘norm’
- This. Is. Not. Enough.
- Don’t get excited about the antibody test being available for everyone too soon – it doesn’t fit with the Government’s fag-packet plan
- Payments going contactless, loans and interest increased by Government Policy instead of being put on hold: look at the flow of money and where this is all going when there is and always was a better way than what we are being told
- Boris has gone too far with the Lockdown and nowhere near enough to mitigate the true cost
- The tolerance of the public is already wafer thin. Failure of politicians to recognise how their decisions will have unseen consequences may quickly push the good will of the People over a very steep edge
- Please avoid the trap of blaming anyone for spreading Coronavirus – no matter how stupid their behaviour appears to be
- The freedom of the media is driving the Public to be confined. There is nothing fair in the exchange
- If ever there was a right time to tell the EU to bugger off, that time is now
- The Government is forcing us to fear life as if it were the same thing as death
- We ALL need bills & interest put on hold and enough money to eat and be clean. Government bullshit about Subsidies, Loans and Grants helping us now or in the long term is simply f**ktarded
- The supermarkets will be able to deliver more online if they simply tell people when they will deliver rather than letting customers decide
- WE ALL NEED TO GET A GRIP PEOPLE: Because this is a Government that could react disastrously wrong to what is now going on
- Seeking financial reparation from China for Coronavirus would be ridiculous. The pay-off should be the warning that today they are not a Government the UK can trust
- Neither the Public or Business can service debt without income. The Chancellor’s Coronavirus ‘help’ is yo-yo politics that flashes in the face but simply doesn’t go that far
- This Government’s retarded view of it’s responsibilities and how the economy works will inflict misery upon small business and generations to come whilst all the usual suspects get a bumper pay day
- This non-stop ‘Coronavirus Show’ is helping nobody
- The Great Reckoning: Is Corona Virus the restart a world driven by money and self interest has been waiting for?
- Government MUST NOT bailout airlines, banks or any privately owned business during the CV Crisis. It should provide standstill legislation that trickles down to support EVERYONE and not just those who believe they are too rich to fail
- The public sector and the way government works in this Country is broken. Change has become vital and Dominic Cummings may have just shown us all where it can all begin
- The #Indyref2 question will only be a problem for Boris whilst Sturgeon continues to frame the debate
- That was the 2019 General Election that was. The UK’s future now depends upon how Boris decides to step beyond
- The Makeshift Manifesto
- Q. Why are the Polls changing? – A. Because nothing else in politics is
- Still not voting…
- As a Licensing Chair I would have understood why TFL has refused to renew Uber’s License. Actually, I wouldn’t have awarded them one in the first place – but that helps nobody now
- Legislators should legislate. Not spend public cash like it simply doesn’t count
- Our Politicians are failing us over flooding, but this is nothing new. ‘Out of sight, out of mind’ is simply the method they use to prioritise everything they do
- Now that Farage has stepped aside to aide the Establishment’s Brexit, what happens if Boris doesn’t win and 17.4 Million Leavers are left with nothing more than multiple versions of Remain?
- Labour’s Universal Basic Income is nothing but a temporary bridge across a black hole of a problem that none of the Parties understand or are prepared to deal with