Archive

Posts Tagged ‘Court’

#KBF & Simon Dolan RIGHTLY get the Lockdown case Appealed. But what difference would a win in Court really make?

August 5, 2020 2 comments

img_8238

Many people from the anti-Lockdown movement will be celebrating today at the news that Simon Dolan and Keep Britain Free have succeeded in winning an Appeal Hearing after the initial effort to get the Lockdown legally overturned failed.

With so much harm having already come to jobs, businesses and the economy, and with culture-changing social distancing measures restricting our routines and daily life at every turn, there is of course much to celebrate in the Case being heard. I am certainly not going to criticise a collective effort that in principle I agree with, especially when we are all very much together in the belief that people are unnecessarily being restricted and hurt by what Johnson and Co have done.

The question is however, what difference would a win in Court really make?

As I suggested in my first Blog about the Case that was then being assembled and the Crowdfunder that had been promoted to get financial support, simply fighting in Court over principles with an Establishment that doesn’t have any is not a process that will result in a genuine win.

Any victory in Court would have been pyric even if the Lockdown had been stopped when the Case was heard in Court before. Because the action itself would not remove either the Government or the existing pool of stupid politicians that we have. That is of course before you consider the irreparable harm that the Lockdown has now done to lives, jobs, businesses and incalculably more.

The problems that are stacking up for us all reach way beyond the loss of jobs, the closure of businesses, the requirement to wear masks, the closure of schools and all the hidden impacts like suicides and significant rises in abuse, depression and anxiety that hardly touches the mainstream news.

Whether we all understand and accept it or not as yet, the solution to these problems will not come from any political movement that operates in an echo chamber like the Brexit Party did in a single-issue form.

The politicians that we have and their whole political class  – and to be clear that’s pretty much all of them – have been wrecking lives, creating division, unfairness and trauma where there was never any need for it to exist long before Coronavirus or Covid-19 came into view.

Any of us attempting to tackle the political problem without a full appreciation of what has happened, is still happening and how politics and government genuinely works in this Country is destined to prop up the existing political party regimes or repeat the same mistakes dressed up differently all over again.

I admire the effort that Simon has made. There is little doubt that his principles are very much in the right place. But the belief that all this can be resolved and a constitution enshrining basic human rights based on Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness can be delivered simply by winning enough votes to influence the politicians that we have is likely to prove very misguided indeed.

As with the European Referendum result before this crisis and then the 2019 European Parliament Elections that followed, Simon may well be right in that a direction of travel can be established through influence alone.

The problem with having stupid politicians in charge however, is it unquestionably the devil in the detail that counts. Just as we have seen with Boris (out of general view during this Crisis) and of course more openly with Trident Tongued Theresa May before.

Sorting this mess out is not a job for normal people.

It is not a job for the normal politicians that we cannot seem to rid ourselves of either.

This is a lot more than simply being about background, experience, qualification, motivation and ideas to make the effort and belief really count.

This is going to need 650 people with a very different, potentially enlightened way of looking at the world, at everything happening, with vision to see and understand the consequences of public policy on everyone, if we are to have a government that delivers results that are genuinely good for and consider us all.

Being in Government at any level is in no way as simple as telling other people what to do. Yes, the systems and the procedures need to be changed, just as the culture of the public sector has to be transformed all the way through.

But to do this and to make it count, there is no option but to take as many people within the system with you as possible and only remove those who will obstruct the change necessary because their current roles give them enough clout.

There has to be a working appreciation of how government already works by anyone in a position of power who wants to change it permanently before that change can begin.

To all of us outside of Westminster who want that change to have begun yesterday, this means putting together a new movement that reaches way beyond the idealistic and attempting to convince and justify to others what should automatically be seen as right.

I wish Simon and KBF well with the Appeal and sincerely hope that they win the Case. It is clearly justified and right.

But as we go forward and more and more of us start to experience the fallout from what these stupid politicians have done and as our freedoms and rights to speak out are infringed ever more, I hope that those who have awoken to what this Government has done will also realise that fighting the Lockdown and the Social Distancing measures being used to cage and restrict us are just battles that are part of a much bigger war.

Winning this for us all is about a lot more than changing opinion, knowing you are right or simple good luck.

Please take a step back. Take a deep breath. Be patient and take the time necessary. Then do the job right.

 

Don’t waste money challenging the Lockdown in Court. Fund a people’s movement for change instead

May 22, 2020 1 comment

It sounds like I’m about to critiscise Simon Dolan for his High Court Action against The Lockdown and the Crowdfunding Campaign he has been championing to find it.

I’m not.

But I can’t support it either.

Not because I don’t agree with the principle of what he is doing.

I do.

I won’t actively support it because the objective itself is a waste of his time and that of his legal team.

The money would be better spent funding a new people’s movement for change. One we will need very soon, when the reality of what the unnecessary Lockdown has done hits home and the UK wakes up to the need for real leadership to get us out of the mess that Boris and his Government created, putting right all that they have done wrong.

One of the most difficult and challenging things that I ever had to do as a Borough Councillor was to explain to consitituents who had valid, justified and correct arguments against the actions of politicians and Government that they would be able to say their piece, but the system would ensure that they wouldn’t be heard if it went against the direction of political travel that day.

It is no different now and the money that Mr Dolan has attracted from many people from across our great country who realise the Lockdown and attack on our liberty was not necessary and has done far more damage than it was ever worth, fills me with hope that we can change the way things work for the better – as long as we play the right game.

The flow of this broken establishment system goes only one way. You can only win by fixing the whole broken thing (which means changing all of it) or by taking action that compliments it and goes exactly the same way.

The Court Action does neither. No matter what exchanges take place, what is reported in the media or how the Government might appear to be criticised in some way, the justification for this argument will not stop the Government from doing what it is doing and will not get a result.

What we all need, more than futile gestures – no matter how well intended they might be – is for people who have something to say and have the ability to get public attention to say it, to make the argument for the need for change and give it real voice.

When the wheels fall off for the Johnson Government as you can be sure they are going to very soon, we do not need a situation where we only have Keir Starmer or whoever is leading the Liberal Democrat’s as the choice.

We will need options that will work for us all. Those options will not come from any of the existing parties, even if words like reform are involved.

Putting right the damage that this Government has done and making the very best use of the opportunities for bottom to top change that will come to improve the lives of everyone in this Nation post COVID-19 requires that we have new blood, new faces and above all new thinking at the top.

Working against the tide of this establishment isn’t easy as the fear they have installed within so many of Coronavirus has shown.

Money, passion and the support of real people like that given to Mr Dolan will be the catalyst for change that this Country will need and the money being spent challenging the Lockdown in Court would be better spent funding a people’s movement for change.

 

%d bloggers like this: